Night Vision Vs. Thermal Scopes: Detailed Guideline
Choosing the right scope for your rifle is not an easy job. Especially if you’re trying to get something that helps in a specific activity – then you’ll have to be extra careful and be confident of what you’re getting.
This is a hot topic and a starter of many discussions among gun enthusiasts. And it happens because both types of scopes let you see at night – but they hold pretty significant differences that can make it or break it for your needs.
Here, we’ll explain everything each type of scope offers and how you can get the most out of them accordingly.
If you’re in search of a scope for low-light use and can’t decide between night-vision or thermal models – then hop on and read further!
What Are Night Vision Scopes?
Let’s start by explaining in-depth what night vision scopes entail. First of all, night vision relies heavily on light exposure.
The greenish pictures you’ve seen on videos, news, movies, and some TVs are night-vision. They are goggles, scopes, or cameras with the NV (night-vision) lenses.
What these lenses do is take even the smallest amounts of lights, magnify them through an intensifier tube, and project them. Then, you’ll see them in a display or through lenses (in case of scopes).
But as you see, night vision relies heavily on ambient light. You can use one of these scopes in the wild or places with tons of stars and moonlight, and there won’t be a problem. They will catch all the illumination particles and reflect them directly through the lenses.
This will look as if the scope were a flashlight. But instead of producing light, it catches it and magnifies it.
In places with no light (e.g., total darkness rooms or deep forests), a night-vision scope won’t work as well.
In contrast, if someone uses a night-vision scope in daylight, there’s a high chance of the device getting damaged. This happens because the level of illumination will be such that the intensifying lenses will just break or burn, as they will be somewhat “overcharged” with light particles.
Still, night vision works wonders on low-light environments. The natural and detailed imagery makes it one of the first choices for night-shooting enthusiasts.
That’s why NV scopes are among the most popular out there, and usually offer excellent builds that handle all kinds of recoils for all sorts of guns.
Night-vision scopes are simple. They rely on low-light and produce high-quality images.
Advantages of Night Vision
No sense in explaining what it offers without eventually going over its benefits:
Disadvantages of Night Vision
Sure, they have some advantages – but they also have a few downsides. Here’s what we mean:
This is a basic explanation of what night vision scopes offer. Now, let’s go over thermal scopes.
What Are Thermal Scopes?
While night-vision scopes rely on light – thermal scopes rely on heat. Or what many people like to call: thermal energy or radiation.
Luckily, almost everything we can see holds some level of thermal energy. And that is what a thermal scope detects; the “heat signature” of every object around.
So, thermal scopes work well regardless of how much light there is as they work with heat instead.
But it is essential to know that all objects and beings produce heat differently. While humans, animals, and machinery produce heat themselves, most objects like rocks and water absorb heat from sources like sunrays, weather, and so on.
That’s why telling different things apart from this type of scope is a piece of cake, especially at night. But they also work in daylight. You can use a thermal scope without problems, even if there’s lots of light around.
And sure enough, total darkness is not a problem either. If you’re inside a blackout room with not a single light source, then a thermal scope will still emit proper imagery of surrounding objects.
Apart from that, thermal imagery doesn’t rely on object shapes. It instead detects according to the heat signature or form of the heat. That’s why it is also super effective at detecting stuff at great distances, or with camouflage. But it suffers when giving form to things with low thermal signature.
Sure, some things are hotter than others, so the warmer something is, the more radiation it will emit, and the more visible it will be in a thermal scope.
Thermal scopes are even more straightforward than night-vision scopes when functioning, but their build requires a little more complexity.
Yet, someone who can take a photo with a phone can also use a thermal scope without issues.
Advantages of Thermal Scopes
If you want to know the benefits of using thermal scopes, here are a few points to consider:
Disadvantages of Thermal Scopes
Thermal scopes are super amazing, but they still have a few downsides:
These are the different things that thermal scopes have going for and against them. Now, let’s explain how all that compares to night vision in specific features.
Night Vision Vs. Thermal Scopes: Features to Consider
When considering every option, it is not enough to learn just a few facts about each. Instead, you’ll want to know as much as you can, comparing and explaining what they offer in all the most critical factors.
Here’s how thermal scopes and night vision differ when considering critical aspects:
Day & Night Use
Most people will use a thermal or NV scope only at night. But some people will not.
In case it is necessary to see through smoke, fog, or dense vegetation, you may also need something that has the upper hand even in daylight. The focus is that you may also need to use scopes when the sun is still up there, even if it seems counter-intuitive.
Here, you’ll find that thermal scopes always perform better. They don’t suffer any damage, and they can still provide outstanding results.
With night-vision scopes, you won’t have the same luck. Most of them will probably get damaged and stop working if you use them in plain daylight. This happens because the sensors may eventually break or burn by overcharging.
But it is still important to mention that some high-end night-vision scopes are actually daylight-friendly. They offer the chance to see through in plain daylight without causing a single problem. Sure enough, these high-end models tend to be hugely expensive.
So, which one is better then? Well, there’s no mistake if you go for the thermal scopes. Even the cheapest one will offer ideal daylight operation while mid-end NV scopes will not.
Detection refers to how easy it is to spot stuff through the scope. This could be utterly helpful when hunting, in surveillance, and more. And sure enough, both types of scopes perform way differently from each other.
When testing thermal imaging, you can see that it will only display objects with a heat signature. Objects that are too cold or don’t have a different heat signature from their surroundings may be challenging to spot.
But luckily, it works wonders when detecting live stuff. From animals to other humans and even vehicles, machinery, and so on – they often produce enough heat to be easily captured through a thermal scope.
With night-vision models, this experience varies. As you won’t see heat at all but only light, then identifying live objects from inanimate stuff is pretty hard. Fortunately, it ensures that you can see much more detail, which allows a more watchable image in which movement is easier to spot.
For spotting objects that stand still, are under fog or smoke, or have camouflage, a night-vision scope can be a little ineffective.
Here, you can see that it depends heavily on what the user prefers, the environment he/she is in, and the object to identify.
For hunting or spotting live things with clear heat signatures at night (e.g., hunting, spotting, etc.), many people would prefer thermal scopes. But for those who want to get more details and identify things that are not necessarily alive, then night-vision scopes are better.
The contrast refers directly to how well the scope can handle different situations and provide the ideal image quality accordingly.
Here, it is evident that night-vision scopes have many downsides. They are usually helpful in ideal scenarios with proper light and not many elements around. But in total darkness, areas with too much light, or too many visual deterrants (vegetation, fog, dust, dirt, etc.), then NV scopes will not farewell.
Instead, thermal scopes offer a decent contrast, no matter the situation. They won’t give shape to things or deliver as much detail as NV models, but thermal scopes will still manage to provide a decent contrast in almost any situation. Whatever there’s in the environment, thermal imagery can get to it.
So, yes – contrast is way better on thermal than it is on NV scopes. But the difference doesn’t necessarily mean that thermal is “always” better.
Instead, you can find the thermal ideal for places with different elements that NV models won’t go through. For ideal environments, NV will offer a higher contrast.
Detecting stuff in the dark and trying to see things that contrast are two significant factors to consider. But how does each scope perform at a distance?
This is difficult to compare between these two types because they have reasonably similar results. However, thermal is somewhat the winner here.
This happens because detecting warmth over long distances takes less effort than detecting light.
But thermal doesn’t make it easy to calculate distance. While NV scopes won’t detect things far away so well, they will make it easy to calculate that distance if possible. And they could also give a better shape to objects thanks to their detail.
The advantage thermal has over night-vision is that heat can be easy to spot at distances of up to 1,000 yards as long as the environment contrasts the object/animal well enough.
But with night-vision, this is lost. You will only see specific things that reflect light. So that’s sort of a disadvantage on long-range usage that makes it hard to see objects at a distance.
So, thermal scopes are better in terms of distance and spotting things on the long-range. But when it comes to calculating or giving shapes to things, it is regular night-vision that wins.
We’ve touched this when talking about detection, contrast, and distance. And it refers to how well each type of scope performs when it is put against different types of environment.
Well, we can easily say that night-vision devices are way better if there’s nothing around. Let’s say you’re scoping on an open field at night in search of deer. Here, an NV scope will perform amazingly well.
But once you add lots of bushes, trees, fog, some dirt, or even a little smoke – then it becomes harder to identify or just see anything through.
With thermal, you won’t have any of those issues. You can still see things even if there are bushes or trees around, fog, smoke, or just anything. As long as the object/animal has a different heat signature to display, then the thermal scope will let you know there’s something there.
However, thermal suffers in extreme temperatures. In freezing or boiling environments, the heat signature of things gets blurry. That makes it hard to spot targets. In contrast, NV scopes won’t have this drawback as they can only see the light that reflects (heat or cold won’t cause any effect).
Here, you could say that in ideal environments with nothing around that could affect visibility; a night-vision scope will perform better – even if it is too hot or cold.
But for places with several visual obstructions like vegetation, fog, dirt, and so on – then a thermal scope will be the best choice.
It is important to note that thermal scopes can’t see through glass or transparent materials while night-vision ones can – so be aware of that before choosing.
We can say that thermal scopes are slightly better if there are environmental limits that don’t affect temperature.
Many people tend to overlook this factor, but it also has great importance when choosing the right scope.
The durability of both thermal and night-vision scopes tends to be similar. But a few decades ago, thermal scopes were slightly worse due to their somewhat more complex mechanisms.
Nowadays, both perform similarly well. There’s almost no difference when it comes to durability between these two. Even in high-recoil guns, these two types of scopes will perform amazingly well.
This is a slightly more difficult thing to consider when comparing night-vision scopes with thermal ones. What happens is that each offers different sub-types to consider.
For example, regular NV scopes usually consist of Gen 1, Gen 2, or Gen 3 models.
A Gen 1 scope refers to a budget-friendly product. It doesn’t have the same durability or image quality as a Gen 2. Then, you’ll find Gen 3 – the one that has the highest-quality image, crispness, ambient light capacity, and longer battery life. All these three versions use an intensifier tube & lenses.
Another night-vision type of scope is the digital one. This one consists of lenses with a coupler device. What it does is receive the light through the lenses then the light goes through the coupler device that processes the image and sends it through an LCD screen.
It doesn’t have the same type of image quality as Gen 1, Gen 2, or Gen 3 – but it is still pretty bright and crisp. Apart from that, digital night vision offers the chance to use during the daytime, which is a huge advantage.
On the other hand, you’ll find the different sub-types of thermal scopes. Here, you will only find two.
The first one is the uncooled scope. It consists of a quiet and easy-to-use mechanism that operates at room temperature. So, it will detect anything colder or hotter than the temperature of the piece.
Then, you’ll find cryogenically cooled thermal scopes. These are slightly colder than the former. The focus is to maintain the system working at less than 32-degrees Fahrenheit. This improves sensitivity and overall resolution, which makes it easy to detect things.
So, which one is better in terms of availability? There’s no clear winner either, yet we can say that you’ll find more variety with night-vision scopes.
As we’ve explained before, most night-vision models tend to be light and easy to handle. They don’t have many different things inside apart from the lenses and the intensifier tube. That makes them light, almost like any other scope.
But thermal models are not so light. This happens because the heat-detecting mechanism tends to have a few more parts and components that add up a little weight. So, they’re not as agile or versatile, and usually 25% heavier than a standard model.
So, yes – night-vision scopes are far lighter, which makes them better for handling and carrying.
Ease of Use
Using either kind of scope is a piece of cake. You won’t find much of a difference between seeing through a thermal scope or aiming with an NV model.
But there’s a slight difference if we’re talking about tactical use or surveillance use, for example.
Due to the heavier design of thermal scopes along with their complex mechanisms, they can be less tactical-oriented. This means that they won’t fare too well in situations where speed & lightness are necessary.
But with night-vision scopes, you won’t have that problem. They’re often half as heavy as thermal models, so you will have a way easier time handling them and bringing them around.
Overall, though, they’re similarly easy to use. But thanks to the slight advantage of NV models, they’re the best in this factor.
This is probably the first thing many people will take into account. And it wouldn’t be a bad idea. The cost of a scope has a significant impact on how well it works, what it offers, and whether you can afford it or not.
For us, there’s no doubt that thermal scopes are the most expensive. They are at least twice as expensive as night-vision scopes for the sole reason that their mechanisms are more complex.
But of course, it all comes down to the sub-type you want. An uncooled thermal scope may be the same price or even less than a Gen 3 scope, for example.
Yet, a cryogenically-cooled thermal scope can be five times more expensive than a Gen 1 NV scope.
Other factors, such as compatibility with guns, extra features, recording capacity, and so on, can also change the price.
But overall, NV models are far cheaper. So if you’re on a low budget, this will be your best bet.
Now, what type of activity will you use the scope for? Typically, people use scopes for hunting – and that would be a great application.
But both types have different advantages here. For example, thermal scopes are useful for environments with lots of vegetation like jungles and thick forests. Many people love hog-hunting with one of these instead of using night-vision scopes.
For places with less vegetation and more open space, a night-vision system may work much better. That’s why hunters on the savannah or steppes prefer NV models.
However, it is essential to mention that thermal scopes can be used almost at any time of the day as they detect heat only. So that gives them a slight boost in hunting performance. Especially in places with lots of intrusive vegetation or similar factors, then a thermal scope will be the best choice.
So, yes – thermal scopes are somewhat better for hunting. Yet, NV models will still perform decently well.
If you’ve ever seen a movie with military personnel operating at night, then you’ve probably seen someone using either night vision or thermal vision.
Of course, both are pretty useful – but one of them is usually better.
Just like hunting, most military operations rely heavily on spotting people (things that exert heat), so thermal scopes are the most common.
Night-vision systems are also helpful and used in many operations, mainly because they’re cheaper. But they’re used for the environment where tactics & speeds are more necessary, and relying on vision or spot alone is not required.
We could even go as far as to say that thermal works better when it is easy to identify subjects (e.g., from far away, with several targets, and those with camouflage), while night-vision works better for tactical situations (entering buildings, attacking compounds, identifying targets face-to-face, etc.)
But for accuracy-oriented operations, most of the military prefers and uses thermal scopes.
Range Shooting Performance
No need to go all seriousness with the use of a scope. You can instead just try range shooting and practice your aim to develop better accuracy.
Of course, if you’re using either NV or thermal scopes, it means you’re shooting at night. And well, there’s a huge difference here.
Most range-shooting is done with inanimate objects that have not much thermal signature. So looking through a thermal scope may not offer too much of a target to shoot. Of course, you may still see a few lines of darkness that could give you an idea of what you’re aiming at – but that won’t be enough.
Instead, night-vision scopes work really well here. Especially if you’re shooting targets on clear moonlight, then you’ll see almost everything clearly. From the colors to the smallest of details, it will be easier to spot them through an NV model.
If you’re range-shooting, then go for NV as a thermal model will not be so useful or easy to use.
Thermal Scopes vs. Night Vision: Which One Is Right for Me?
So, what type of night system should you go for when choosing your next scope? For us – it all depends.
With so many features and things to consider, coming to a definite answer won’t be easy. So let’s summarize everything we’ve learned so far.
Night-vision scopes consist of an intensifier tube that captures the light and lenses that transmit it. This helps to deliver an excellent night vision in low-light environments.
These work better when you need speed, want to identify things up close, and there aren’t many intrusive objects or stuff that may block your vision.
Thermal scopes are a little more complicated, consisting of lenses and a thermal device that transforms the infrared energy into an image. They are ideal for places with less light and when there’s too much fog, dirt, dust, or vegetation.
Also, you’ll find them useful for situations where you don’t need much speed or get close to objects. And sure enough, they’re also helpful in the daytime if you want to detect stuff through heat.
Let’s now explain more straightforwardly.
Why Choose a Night Vision Scope?
Why Choose a Thermal Scope?
Choose the Right Type of Scope Now!
When using a new type of scope to have eyes at night, you’ll find thermal and night-vision to be so similar that it won’t easy to pick one.
But still, you can decide which one to pick by taking into consideration what they offer on brief, and how you can get the most out of each accordingly.
This is what we recommend you to choose by:
If you prefer something simple and affordable that works for most situations – go for a night-vision scope.
For something more precise that doesn’t let anything get in its way – go for a thermal model.
Choose by taking these two statements into consideration, and you’ll probably end up with the right option. Still, take your time and read the entire article – you won’t regret learning in-depth about each.